Have you ever heard of a spite house? If not, you shouldn’t be ashamed or surprised. After all, these houses built to annoy aren’t that common in America. Furthermore, famous buildings like the Richardson House have already been demolished. On the other hand, although primarily unusual in shape or size, some of these odd-looking homes are now quite valuable. The following are 10 of the best-known spite houses in America that are still in existence.
What is a Spite House?
As the term suggests, a spite house is built to annoy or offend a neighbor or “any party with land stakes.” In other words, it’s a house made to antagonize someone or some entity due to a disagreement. For instance, you may find that some spite houses were built to obstruct a neighbor’s view while others were constructed as a divorce settlement. Other examples are property disagreements with local governments, blocking an alleyway, or blocking lights in another home. In other cases, these houses are also known as skinny houses or pie houses and look exactly how they sound.
What is the Oldest Spite House in America?
These types of quirky houses date to the 18th century in America. The oldest known still standing in America is likely the Old Spite House in Marblehead, Massachusetts; however, there are some other examples worldwide. Different forms of spite are spite monuments and, most commonly, spite fences.
Please Note:
Many of the following houses are privately owned. If you visit any of these, please be mindful of its occupants’ privacy. That’s not to mention the neighborhood in which these homes can be found. The last location on this list is the Pink House, which can only be viewed from the road since it’s on private federal property.
Alameda Spite House
2528 Crist St.
Alameda, CA 94501
www.atlasobscura.com/alamedaspitehouse
According to several sources, this skinny house was built to annoy the city and a neighbor. In the early 1900s, Charles Froling owned land at the corner of Crist Street and Broadway. These same sources claim the City of Alameda (near Oakland) took a portion of Froling’s property for a street expansion. So, to annoy the city and neighbors, Froling built this 10-foot-wide home in 1908 in the remaining portion of his property. Although just 10 feet wide, 20 feet tall, and 54 feet long, it has nearly 1150 square feet of space.
Related: Hyatt Centric: A Top Choice in San Francisco’s Fisherman’s Wharf
Cake House
Kent Road and Riverview Road
New Milford, CT 06755
You shouldn’t be surprised that this five-tiered house is also called the Wedding Cake House. That’s because it resembles a wedding cake, with five tiers without the figurines on top. Before its completion, owner Jan Pol and his wife had their pregnant adopted daughter taken away by the child welfare department. What’s more, the Pols were never able to retain custody of their adopted daughter. Today, the Cake House has no occupants, but you might be able to tour its interior. Either way, you can find this pyramid-like building in the Gaylordsville neighborhood of New Milford.
Deerfield Pie House
970 Chestnut St.
Deerfield, IL 60015
www.wikipedia.com/piehouse
If you see the Pie House up front, it looks like a very nice suburban home outside Chicago. However, walking behind it may resemble an artificial home from a Hollywood studio backlot. In reality, this home, which is the shape of a pie, is only three feet wide and was built in 2003 to fit a narrow lot. While this home was not originally built with spite, its neighbors were indeed not happy. Today, the Pie House is quite famous, having been seen on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, NBC Chicago, and even TikTok. It’s not far from the Deerfield Metra station north of downtown Chicago if you hope to visit.
Hollensbury Spite House
423 Queen St.
Alexandria, VA 22314
The Hollensbury House is frequently known as America’s skinniest, occupying a narrow space in Old Town Alexandria. That’s because this historic home measures just 7 feet 6 inches wide. It’s so narrow that many visitors with extended arms will pose in front to reach either end. Before its completion in 1830, this was an alley next to the home of John Hollensbury. Not only did the alley attract loiterers but also horse-drawn wagons that damaged his adjoining brick walls. In light of this, Hollensbury bought the alley and built it as an extension of his home, and in the years since the Hollensbury House has been under private ownership.
Related: Unusual New Year’s Traditions From Around the World
Miracle House
145 Lena Ave.
Freeport, NY 11520
This normal-looking home is far from being skins. On the other hand, the Miracle House fits in the same category as all of these others. In this case, the Miracle House was built just one day to annoy a competitor in a real estate development race. Despite being primarily built in a single day, it’s a two-story home with seven bedrooms and 2.5 baths. If you wish to see the Miracle House, it’s the Freeport neighborhood of Hempstead on Long Island. From Manhattan, you can take a Long Island Railroad route to the village of Freeport.
Montlake Spite House
2022 24th Ave. E
Seattle, WA 98112
Like the Deerfield Pie House, looks can be deceiving at this unusual Seattle home. Resembling a cheese or pie wedge or simply a piece of cheesecake, this oddity has not one but three explanations. However, all three explanations are due to some land dispute between one or more neighbors. As a result, you have an 860-square-foot two-story home built in 1925 with two bedrooms and 1.75 bedrooms. By viewing it on the side, you’ll notice that it’s just 15 feet at its most comprehensive and under 6 feet at its narrowest. Despite its tiny size, the home has a current value of over $600,000. As for public transportation options, you can take either bus routes 43 or 48 from the heart of Seattle.
O’Reilly House
Now in use as one of Boston’s smallest commercial spaces, the O’Reilly Spite house is a perfect example of revenge. In a bit more detail, this unusual building was built by Francis O’Reilly after his neighbor refused to purchase his small plot of land. This building, built in 1908, is just 308 square feet and 8 feet at its widest. Furthermore, it’s much narrower at its backside at a mere 4 feet. Also known as the Cambridge Spite House, it’s within minutes of the Public Library, with public bus access a block away.
Skinny House
44 Hull St.
Boston, MA 02113
Set in the oldest neighborhood of Boston, you shouldn’t underestimate the value of the Skinny House. After all, this historic home wasn’t long ago sold for $1.25 million or €1.17 million. You can trace the two-story building to what sources say was a property dispute between two brothers sometime after the Civil War. When one of the two brothers returned from service, he discovered that the other brother built a large home occupying most of the property. In an act of revenge, the returning soldier built a tiny house to block the view from the larger house. If you visit, it’s in the North End neighborhood and covers 1,000 square feet with two bedrooms.
Related: America’s Most Famous Haunted Houses to Visit for Halloween
Thomas McCobb House
Deadman Point
Rockport, ME 04856
Built in 1806, the Thomas McCobb House resulted from a family feud. The son of an Irish immigrant, Thomas McCobb, was away at sea when his father died. Before he made it back home, his father’s will was altered to include his stepmother’s son. Upon returning home, he discovered that his stepbrother inherited the original home in Phippsburg. For this reason, Thomas built his Federal-style home to overshadow the older home. After years of disrepair, the barge moved the home to its present location at Deadman Point.
Tyler’s-Spite House
112 W. Church St.
Frederick, MD 21701
With 9,200 square feet and seven bedrooms and baths, this isn’t your ordinary spite house. However, you may wonder why someone would want to build such a house in a land dispute. That credit goes to Dr. John Tyler, a prominent ophthalmologist best known as one of the earliest to perform cataract surgery. According to sources, Dr. Tyler learned that the city planned to extend a street right by his home. To prevent this from happening, he began building a second home to block the construction. Recent records show that this enormous home served as a bed and breakfast. It is not clear whether it is currently being used as a B&B or for other businesses.
Bonus Selection
The Pink House
60 Plum Island Turnpike
Newbury, MA 01951
www.supportthepinkhouse.com
Despite being a frequent entry amongst America’s spite houses, the Pink House may not be precisely what has been claimed. Some sources say the Pink House was built as part of a divorce settlement. This 1925 home on Plum Island was built as an identical home that a couple once shared. However, the wife allegedly did not specify the extent to which the building would be built. In response, the husband built the home on a remote island section. However, Support the Pink House has done extensive research on the history of this unoccupied house. Their findings determined there is no evidence that this ever occurred. Now, under the ownership of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife and Parker River National Wildlife Refuge, it’s closed to the public.
Related: Most Unusual Christmas Trees in America
About The Author
Randy Yagi is an award-winning freelance writer who served as the National Travel Writer for CBS from 2012 to 2019. More than 900 of his stories still appear in syndication across 23 CBS websites, including New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, and San Francisco. During his peak years with CBS, Randy had a reported digital audience reach of 489 million and 5.5 million monthly visitors. Additionally, his stories have appeared in the Daily Meal, CBS News, CBS Radio, Engadget, NBC.com, NJ.com, and Radio.com. He earned a Media Fellowship from Stanford University in 2012.